Case Summaries for Nov. 13-19, 2026
Each week, The Missouri Bar provides links to all hand downs published online during the past seven days by the Supreme Court of Missouri and the Missouri Court of Appeals. The Missouri Bar has created headings and summaries for each case. Summaries are not part of the opinions of the Court. They have been prepared for the convenience of the reader and should not be quoted or cited.
Appellate | Civil | Consumer | Criminal | Employment | Family | Orders of protection | Personal injury | Post-conviction | Real estate
Appellate
Defenses, objections, points waived
A pre-answer motion to dismiss that failed to raise personal jurisdiction constituted a waiver of that defense. Failure to object to the entry of evidence barred those matters from appeal. The appellants abandoned any point unsupported by citations to authority, including failing to address statutory factors for determining forum non conveniens. Points addressing more than one ruling or one theory were multifarious and preserved nothing for review. The Missouri Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment.
(Overview summary)
Sousan Loghmani and Golnaz Iman v. Nader Afzali
Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District - WD88179
Certification was no good
Judgments that were not final were still within appellate court jurisdiction if certified in circuit court. The circuit court’s certification was also subject to appellate review. The minimum portion of a judgment subject to certification was a judicial unit, meaning either all claims as to one party or one claim as to all parties. Distinct meant, not just different theories, but different facts, transactions, and occurrences. The parties were litigating liability for an encroachment onto a city sewer line easement among landowners, the city, and city employees. The city sued the landowners and the landowners brought counterclaims against the city and also named the employees. The judgment resolved counterclaims against the employees, but not all against the city, and the city’s claim against the landowners remained unresolved. Therefore, no judicial unit was resolved in circuit court. The certification was erroneous, so the Missouri Court of Appeals dismissed the appeal.
(Overview summary)
City of Washington, Respondent, v. Todd Hendricks, and Leisa Hendricks, Appellants, v. Donald E. Peters, et al., Respondents
Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District - ED114402
Civil
No error in action underlying attorney fees appeal
Motions for attorney fees constituted a separate action from the underlying action from which the movant sought fees. The appellants challenging awards based on errors in underlying actions had first to prevail on appeal of the underlying action, which the appellant failed to do. Challenges to the form or language of the judgment had to appear in a motion to amend or were waived. That applied to the judgment citing authority and making relevant findings of fact. A motion to set aside filed after the judgment became final did not meet that requirement. Points on appeal not supported by an incomplete record on appeal were subject to dismissal.
(Overview summary)
Sousan Loghmani and Golnaz Iman v. Nader Afzali
Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District - WD88344
Consumer
Warranty of merchantability not disclaimed
The Uniform Commercial Code provided that all sales implied a warranty of merchantability and that sellers could disclaim such a warranty with the words “as is” “unless the circumstances indicate otherwise.” Circumstances indicating otherwise included a statement expressly stating that the subject dump truck had an emissions system conforming to law, the unlawful deletion of an emission system, hidden even from the buyer’s inspection, rendering the sale and use illegal. Alternative remedies were possible, cost of repair was not controlling, and the circuit court did not err in using the difference between the value paid and the value received. The Missouri Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment.
(Overview summary)
B & P Excavating, LLC v. Mid-MO Equipment, LLC, et al.
Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District - WD88554
Criminal
Contrary evidence ignored on appeal
In circuit courts are fact-finders and the facts found receive deference on appeal, so circuit courts ignore evidence inconsistent with the facts as found in circuit court. The elements of possessing a controlled substance included knowledge of the substance’s presence and nature. On appeal, the defendant argued that the record did not support the element of knowledge. To support that challenge, the defendant cited evidence contrary to the verdict. The Missouri Court of Appeals affirmed the conviction.
STATE OF MISSOURI, Plaintiff-Respondent v. ASHLEY L. NEWKIRK, Defendant-Appellant
Missouri Court of Appeals, Southern District - SD39240
Evidence was irrelevant to self-defense
On a claim of self-defense, facts showing that the defendant reasonably feared harm were irrelevant unless the defendant knew of such facts when using force against the victim. That included the victim’s previous acts of violence. The defendant offered evidence possibly showing that the victim had committed identity theft on third parties, but did not show that such evidence was the result of violence, and did not show that the defendant knew about that evidence when using force against the victim. And the defendant entered other evidence supporting his defense. The Missouri Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions.
STATE OF MISSOURI, Plaintiff-Respondent v. CHARLES NELSON, Defendant-Appellant
Missouri Court of Appeals, Southern District - SD39100
Employment
No instruction addressed cumulative violations
A hearsay objection did not preserve an objection to improper bolstering and the appellant did not seek plain error review of that theory. Cumulative evidence was never prejudicial, including a supervisor’s notes of the plaintiff’s inadequate job performance. When no approved instruction applied to a claim, the instruction had to track the law. In actions under the Human Rights Act, no approved instruction applied to retaliation. The appellant did not show that the appellant could have prevailed by demonstrating neither one violation of the act, nor another violation, “but does somehow prove a violation of both [.]” And the appellant did not offer such a proposed instruction. The Missouri Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment.
(Overview summary)
Dale Good v. Missouri Department of Corrections
Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District - WD88347
Damages reversed
The filing of actions, administrative or judicial, for discrimination, discrete or continuing, were subject to time limits. For continuing discrimination, the plaintiffs had to show at least one incident during the limitations period, and such an incident made relevant earlier incidents. The plaintiff showed a hostile work environment by showing disparate wages; and showed constructive discharge by showing that the employer lied about relief from disproportionate workload and wage; and both were recent enough. Evidentiary rulings were subject to review de novo on the law but with deference on the facts. The plaintiff testified that the plaintiff drafted a resignation letter to frame issues for consultation with counsel, and that testimony supported exclusion as attorney client communication. Disclosure in discovery did not waive the attorney/client privilege, especially when done by mistake. Objections to instructions were due during the instructions conference and motions for new trial were too late. Hostile work environment depended on a pattern of conduct, not specific incidents, so instructions did not have to address specific incidents. For constructive discharge, deviating from the approved instruction on mitigation of damages constituted error because it raised the standard of proof for the employer. And it caused prejudice by disregarding relevant evidence of actual damages. And actual damages were the predicate of punitive damages. The Missouri Court of Appeals reversed the judgment, and remanded the action for a new trial, as to damages. The Court of Appeals also granted the plaintiff’s motion for attorney fees on appeal as to the points on which the plaintiff prevailed on appeal, and remanded the action for a determination of that award.
(Overview summary)
Sheila Gassner v. Lincoln University Board of Curators to Lincoln University
Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District - WD87999
Family
Custody ruling misapplied the law
In custody determinations, the child’s best interest was paramount. Non-custodial parents were entitled to reasonable visitation so that parents had approximately equal parenting time, which the parties and the guardian ad litem sought. Recent evidence showed great improvement in the parties’ communications. The circuit court awarded sole physical and legal custody to respondent with brief supervised visitation to appellant. The judgment cited a factor related to violence and threats of violence but made no corresponding findings of fact, and respondent had alleged none. Appellant’s texts from six and seven years in the past showed abusive and coercive behavior to respondent but not the child. The circuit court relied on the texts, focused on punishing appellant, not furthering the child’s best interest. The circuit court misapplied the law, so the Court of Appeals reversed the judgment and remanded the action.
R.R.K., minor, By Next Friend STEPHANIE FOX, and STEPHANIE FOX, Individually, Petitioners-Respondents v. MIGUEL KELLER, Respondent-Appellant
Missouri Court of Appeals, Southern District - SD39199
Orders of protection
Renewal misapplied the law
The Adult Abuse act was “intended to prevent potential violence, not hurt feelings or harm to reputation [,]” so social media posts did not support full orders of protection explicitly addressed to, and truly threatening the plaintiff. Full orders of protection were subject to renewal if “the circumstances forming the basis for the initial order continue to exist and a failure to renew will place the petitioner in an immediate and present danger of abuse.” The circuit court correctly declared such law but misapplied that law when the circuit court renewed the order against the appellant without findings on the relevant facts. Instead, the circuit court renewed the order to emphasize the serious nature of its orders based on a social media post that did not indicate any present and immediate danger. The Missouri Court of Appeals reversed the judgment.
(Overview summary)
C.L.B., Respondent, v. C.E.H., Appellant.
Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District - ED113972
Personal injury
Stopping at a red light was discretionary
Official immunity barred suit against public employees in their individual capacities for negligence conducting official duties. Official immunity applied to discretionary conduct, meaning conduct that could vary in time and manner of execution, even if execution was mandatory. Stopping at a red light was mandatory but “[d]riving is discretionary, and thus official immunity protects [defendant driver] from suit.” An exception for malicious conduct did not apply because malice means intent to harm, which the plaintiff did not allege.
(Overview summary)
Alexandria Vargas v. Jackson County, Missouri, et al.
Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District - WD88448
Post-conviction
Ruling on motion mandated
“Mandamus is appropriate to compel a [circuit court] to file an appropriate final judgment.” The circuit court had issued a docket entry denying relief but did not denominate that entry as a judgment and denied a motion to do so. The Missouri Court of Appeals made permanent its writ of mandamus requiring the circuit court to sign and enter a written judgment.
STATE OF MISSOURI, EX REL, GERALD J. COFIELD, Relator v. THE HONORABLE DAVID R. MUNTON, Respondent
Missouri Court of Appeals, Southern District - SD39482
Plea counsel’s assistance was not ineffective
Plea counsel could be ineffective only by failing to communicate, or misadvising about, a plea offer. The State never made an offer and the record showed that the movant would not have accepted it. Trial strategy to which the movant agreed could not support relief. The movant agreed that certain impeachment evidence would have mostly supported the State’s case, offered no defense for the movant, and should not be offered. The circuit court denied relief and the Missouri Court of Appeals affirmed that judgment.
KEETON H. WARING, Movant-Appellant v. STATE OF MISSOURI, Respondent-Respondent
Missouri Court of Appeals, Southern District - SD39329
No relief from the movant’s own choice of strategy
“The failure of a strategy knowingly and voluntarily pursued by the defendant does not entitle him to another try under the guise of ineffective assistance of counsel.” So, when the movant said that he wanted a full trial with no mistrial, pursuing that objective could not support relief. The circuit court denied relief and the Missouri Court of Appeals affirmed that judgment.
JAVONTA D. RAZOR, Appellant v. STATE OF MISSOURI, Respondent
Missouri Court of Appeals, Southern District - SD39160
Real estate
Deed of release was due
The elements of an action for deed of release included full payment of a loan secured by a deed of trust. The judgment included no finding on that element but such a finding was presumed in accordance with the award and had support in the record. The elements of an action for tortious interference with a contract included unjustified conduct, which the plaintiffs showed with evidence that the lenders refused to provide a deed of release. Refusing a payoff amount, and demanding an easement over the subject property, negated any legitimate interest. The Missouri Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment and remanded the action for a determination of attorney fees on appeal.
(Overview summary)
Joseph C. Barber and Brenda L. Barber v. Kimberly R. Weger
Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District - WD88284
